And so my adventures in Muffinland continue, and believe me when I say that I have nothing new to add to the subject of muffins. They remain my go-to baking item in the kitchen. You really cannot mess them up. Mix the liquids, mix the solids, mix the two together and spoon into tins. Nothing to mess up. Promise.
That being said, there are muffins and there are muffins. If you are unsatisfied with the descriptive nature of the previous sentence, let me elaborate. There are muffins that sound good and taste fine, but really, it’s just a lot of flour, eggs, milk, butter and sugar. A day later it’s a bit dry, still sweet so you can take care of that tooth, but your memory is uninspired, and that muffin goes into “forget about this” box in your brain. It’s a So-So Muffin
And then there are muffins. These ones sound good, taste good, still taste good the day after. These muffins are full of flavours and texture; you don’t bite into one and think, flour, you think, Moist! Surprise! I Want More! You want more because this muffin has crunch and squish and colour and a variety of flavours that dance on your tongue. Maybe it has some pieces of fruit or nuts mixed into it, and of course it is tender and stays tender for a few days. This is the Awesome Muffin.
I am no baking expert, but I’ve come up with a little system for myself as a way of determining whether a muffin will be a So-So or the Awesome from looking at ingredients. Yoghurt – Greek yoghurt – especially goes a long way in making a muffin moist for days and buttermilk as well. I realize now after making these muffins that milk is the weakest link in the muffin-making process. The other thing that the Awesome Muffin needs are ingredients that give it texture and complex flavours – fruit, nuts, anything that will burst in the mouth or crunch against the teeth, and more flavour than vanilla essence.
These muffins – Coffee Coffee Cake Muffins by Joy the Baker – are good, but definitely go into the So-So Muffin category for me. The highlight is definitely the brown butter taste, and that was fabulous. I ate the batter by the spoonful; it was that delicious, but I actually liked the batter better than the muffin. Batter better. Say that one a few times fast. I put heaps of espresso in the coffee part of the batter, and it was still lost in the muffin (the coffee taste was faint but could have been stronger).
- Coffee Coffee Cake Muffins (by Joy the Baker) Head over to her site for the recipe. It’s a good muffin, just not great. I wonder how it would change if yoghurt was substituted for the milk. I personally thought the topping was ok but a bit time consuming. I put more time into these muffins than I did into this one and this one, and the other two are significantly better than this coffee cake one. Still everyone who ate it liked this muffin, and I liked it as well, and it would be a nice addition to a brunch table.



